Kevin Noble Maillard
New parents constantly receive advice — mostly unsolicited — from seasoned parents. While women get tips about diapering, nursing or strollers, men tend to get stentorian directives about their new roles as fathers. One piece of advice I received sticks out in my mind: “When the baby comes, just do whatever your lady tells you to do. She knows everything.”
I would never have guessed obedience to be the best attribute of male parenting. But it speaks loudly of the presumed noninterest of men and their disengagement as parents. It’s a different way of asking the question, “Where are all the men?”
As I begin to enter this new world of caregiving, I notice a conspicuous absence of Y chromosomes in curious places. Diaper ads are directed to “hardworking moms.” Parenting sections of book stores have about three (if that) dusty volumes of books directed to men. And Amazon Mom cuts off half of the parent population just because the title sounds good. (The corporate explanation: " 'Amazon Primary Caretaker' just didn’t have the same ring to it.")
Even in the never-ending mommy wars — which are supposedly about parenting — men don’t figure as soldiers in the battle. Fights about the best ways to raise children exist in this strange Gilmanesque HerLand, where men have few roles other than not disturbing the existing discussion. Agreeing and absorbing yes, but public skepticism of the Holy Attachment Trinity of co-sleeping, baby-wearing and breastfeeding is sure to set the blogosphere afire. Imagine if a man had written Elisabeth Badinter’s "The Conflict." La Leche League and every doula in the country would have declared maternal mutiny.
Can men talk about mothering, or is that women only? It’s quite easy to quote deplorable statistics of gender inequality to justify the parental “othering” of men: women earn 77 cents for every man’s dollar; men underperform in household duties and “the year of the woman” celebrates a handful of women elected to office. It’s also easy and even more shortsighted to make a categorical declaration that certain parenting practices are simply better for children because “mothers know best.”
So what if fewer men attend P.T.A. meetings, hoard coupons to BuyBuyBaby, or know the difference between Cixous and Irigaray? Is that really a reason to wave the white flag and default to mothers as primary caretakers and proponents of the conversation? With such low expectations about men’s interest and capacity for parenting, there is little encouragement for change.
Kevin Noble Maillard is a law professor at Syracuse University. He is the co-editor of “Loving v. Virginia in a Post Racial World: Rethinking Race, Sex, and Marriage,” which will be published later this month.
This piece appeared online in the New York Times “Room for Debate” column on June 15.
June 05, 2012 The program, designed in collaboration with the Casting Society of America, was developed for casting students, including key professional components and core courses with fellow Tepper students.
Read more
August 24, 2012 Natalie Teale, a senior Earth sciences and geography major in Syracuse University’s College of Arts and Sciences, spent the summer as part of an immersive research experience in the cloud forest of Costa Rica.
Read more
September 13, 2012 Syracuse University today announced that it has surpassed its goal for the most ambitious fundraising effort in the institution’s history.
Read more
September 10, 2012 Civil engineering professor Cliff Davidson had a breathtaking view of the City of Syracuse from a rooftop garden recently. But it’s the possibilities of that prime location that made the experience memorable.
Read more
September 10, 2012 Trauma, psychiatric medications, family therapy, nutrition and systems reform are a sampling of the topics experts from across the country will discuss at the Children’s Mental Health Summit, September 27-29 in Syracuse.
Read more
